“…nless persuaded that they were clearly wrong. That is an entirely conventional approach to authority: Colchester Estates (Cardiff) Ltd v Carlton Industries plc [1986] Ch 80; Re Cromptons Leisure Machines Ltd [2006] EWHC 3583 (Ch), [2007] BCC 214. The judge said at [79]:…”
“…s and Piepenbrock. He found the reasoning in Piepenbrock to be more persuasive and he would follow it. It may be that, applying Colchester Estates plc v Carlton[1986] Ch 80, it was his duty to follow Piepenbrock unless he considered that it was wrong, which he did not.…”
“…2 KB 153, page 155. There is good reason for the rule and I should depart from it only if convinced that Miss Theis was wrong: Colchester Estates v Carlton Plc [1986] Ch 80, page 85. I am not. On the contrary, I agree with both her decision and her reasoning. As Mr Malek submitted, many of the reasons for giving article 22 reflexi…”