- Cited — Neurim Pharmaceuticals (1991) Limited & Anor. v Generics (UK) Limited & Anor. 2022-03-29
“…[1998] EMLR 161 at 168 that, when deciding who is the successful party for the purpose of determining the incidence of costs:…”
- Cited — Loveridge v Loveridge 2021-11-19
“…003] 1 WLR 60 , para 16, per Sir Murray Stuart-Smith, adopting (post-CPR) the conventional (pre-CPR) approach he described in Roache v News Group Newspapers Ltd[1998] EMLR 161 , 172.…”
- Cited — Deepchand & Anor v Sooben 2020-10-29
“…The correct approach of an appellate court to appeals on costs is that described by Stuart-Smith LJ in Roache v News Group Newspapers Ltd [1998] EMLR 161 at 172 and cited with approval by Lord Woolf MR in AEI Rediffusion Ltd v Phonographic Performance Ltd [1999] 1 WLR 1507 at 1523:…”
- Applied — Parveen, R (on the application of) v London Borough of Redbridge 2020-03-12
“…do so against the background of the test to be applied to appeals concerned with costs, articulated by Sir Murray Stuart-Smith in Roache v Newsgroup Newspapers [1998] EMLR 161, when he said at page 172:…”
- Applied — Lejonvarn v Burgess & Anor 2020-02-06
“…do so against the background of the test to be applied to appeals concerned with costs, articulated by Sir Murray Stuart-Smith in Roache v Newsgroup Newspapers [1998] EMLR 161, when he said at page 172:…”
- Cited — Bishop & Anor v Transport for London 2019-04-05
“…3] 1 WLR 60 at [16] per Sir Murray Stuart-Smith, adopting (post-CPR) the conventional (pre-CPR) approach he described in Roache v News Group Newspapers Limited [1998] EMLR 161 at page 172).…”
- Cited — Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC & Anor v WPMC Ltd & Anor 2018-09-06
“…olly wrong because the court is forced to the conclusion that he has not balanced the various factors fairly in the scale." (Roache v News Group Newspapers Ltd [1998] EMLR 161 per Stuart-Smith J. at p. 172; cited with approval in AEI Rediffusion Music Ltd v Phonographic Performance Ltd [1999] 1 WLR, 1507 per Lord Woolf MR at p. 1523)…”
- Cited — Sirketi v Kupeli & Ors 2018-05-31
“…3] 1 WLR 60 at [16] per Sir Murray Stuart-Smith, adopting (post-CPR) the conventional (pre-CPR) approach he described in Roache v News Group Newspapers Limited [1998] EMLR 161 at page 172).…”
- Cited — SM (Afghanistan) v The Secretary of State for the Home Department 2018-01-24
“… is only necessary to refer to two. The first case which Miss Collier for the respondent drew to our attention is Roache v Newsgroup Newspapers Ltd and others, [1998] EMLR 161. In the first paragraph of his judgment at page 172, Stuart-Smith LJ said that the Court of Appeal must not be tempted to interfere with the judge's costs orde…”